Random Groovy Bible Facts
  • Home
  • F.A.Q.s
  • Seek & You Shall Find
  • Books by Jeremy C. Springfield
  • Recommended Reading
    • Biblical Resources
    • Mishnah & Gemara (Talmud)
    • Jewish Perspectives on the New Testament
    • The Jewish Messiah
    • Chassidut
    • Abraham Joshua Heschel
    • Kabbalah
  • Artículos en español
    • Ungir al Mesías
    • Sefer HaMoshiakh
    • Mesías El Gusano
    • Setenta Luces para las Naciones
    • Ley del la Corazón
    • Torás de Fuego Blanco y Negro
    • Muchas Coronas
    • Mana del Cielo
    • El Cuerpo de las Almas
    • El Shofar de la Ruptura
    • La Shin de Isaac
    • Yonah Kippur en español
    • La Sukáh del Centurión
    • Entre Querubines
    • El Tabernáculo Nublado
    • Discípulos del Mesías
    • Lo Que El Faraón Nunca Supo
    • El Evangelio de Golgotha
  • Audio Studies
  • 2013 Studies
    • Up A Tree
    • The Four Horsemen of the Torah
    • So Many Crowns >
      • Muchas Coronas
    • Why Did Jonah Run Away?
    • Walking On Water
    • The Number of the Beast in the Garden of Eden
    • Peter's Denial and the Cock's Crow
    • Laying Tefillin At the End of Time
    • The Debt of Love
    • Hard to Say or Hard to Do?
    • Finding the Ladder
    • When Satan Fell
    • Sometimes Reaping Takes a Lifetime
    • The Song of Moses
    • Purim in the Torah
    • Messiah the Worm >
      • Mesías El Gusano
    • The Temple Body
    • Anointing Messiah >
      • Ungir al Mesías
    • Law of the Heart >
      • Ley del la Corazón
    • David's Son is His Lord?
    • Faith-Based Foodie
  • 2014 Studies
    • The Seven Books of Torah
    • The Gospel of the Tanakh
    • A Life Laid Down
    • Bread and Water
    • Grafting Gentiles
    • Moving Beyond Kharan
    • The Word and the Lamp
    • Four Feathered Wings
    • The Sign of Blood
    • Love Your Neighbor
    • Disciples of Messiah >
      • Discípulos del Mesías
    • The Shofar of Brokenness >
      • El Shofar de la Ruptura
    • Manna From Heaven >
      • Mana del Cielo
    • Sefer haMoshiakh >
      • Sefer HaMoshiakh en español
    • Seventy Lights for the Nations >
      • Setenta Luces para las Naciones
  • 2015 Studies
    • Preserved with Pivots
    • Purim's Hidden Trees
    • Sons of ... Thunder?
    • What Pharaoh Never Knew >
      • Lo Que El Faraón Nunca Supo
    • Israel's Secret Descendant
    • Follow the Traditions?
    • The Virgin Birth in Torah
    • Two Hands for Benjamin
    • The Signs of Jonah
    • Wisdom's Works
    • In the Carpenter's Shadow
    • Voice of the Shofar
    • A Tabernacles Nativity
    • Crown of Sorrows
    • The Burning Coal
  • 2016 Studies
    • Looking at Leah
    • Elements of Faith
    • Tearing a Prophet Apart
    • The Spirit of Elijah and the Crucifixion
    • Never Spoke a Man Like This
    • Anointed for War
    • The Spirit at Shavuot
    • His Prayer for Us
    • The Pharisee Who Followed
    • A Time to Remember
    • Yonah Kippur >
      • Yonah Kippur en español
    • His Temptation
  • 2017 Studies
    • At the Door
    • Connecting the Dots
    • Fool Me Once
    • Spoken To
    • Yehoseyf
    • Moedim Tovim
    • The Bleeding Temple
    • String Theory Torah
    • Dedicate the House
    • Tongues in Torah
  • 2018 Studies
    • The Centurion's Sukkah >
      • La Sukáh del Centurión
    • Unnatural Forgiveness
    • Eyes of Flesh and Faith
    • Isaac's Shin >
      • La Shin de Isaac
    • What Satan Never Wanted
    • The Greatest and the Least
    • My Goodness
    • A High Priest in Hell
    • Kissing the Son
    • Atop the Skull
    • Lehadlik Ner Chanukah
    • The Hidden Spies
  • 2019 Studies
    • The Sword of Shema
    • Hastening the Day
    • Mashiach bat Avichayil
    • The Cloudy Tabernacle >
      • El Tabernáculo Nublado
    • What a Blessing
    • The Man in the Mirror
    • Of Such is the Kingdom
    • All Hail Caesar
    • Synoptic Tefillin
    • Few the Chosen
    • Waters of Unbecoming
    • Nittel Nacht
  • 2020 Studies
    • To Follow a Rebel Rabbi
    • Under A Tree
    • More Than Sparrows
    • Ruth's Vavless Verses
    • Expect the Unexpected
    • The Samaritan Messiah
    • The Baptist
    • Torahs of Black and White Fire >
      • Torás de Fuego Blanco y Negro
    • What the Shofar Says
    • The Nameless One
    • Descending to Ascend
    • The Chanukah Revelation
  • 2021 Studies
    • Release the Prisoner
    • Esther Unveiled
    • In His Image
    • The Narrow Way
    • Wings of a Dove
    • Your Mother's Torah
    • Word Made Flesh
    • Guf Haneshamot >
      • El Cuerpo de las Almas
    • Between Cherubim >
      • Entre Querubines
    • The Gospel of Golgotha >
      • El Evangelio de Golgotha
    • The Fullness
    • Simon Says
  • 2022 Studies
    • The Rock that Followed
    • Anochi
    • Honor of the Call
    • The Dog
    • The Advocate
    • The First and the Last
    • Not Giving to Dogs & Swine
    • Who is Good
    • The Prodigals
    • Verses Versus Verses
    • The Frogs
    • Let it Shine
  • 2023 Studies
    • The Gate of Tears
    • Bearing Fruit
    • The Two Witnesses

MEM SOFIT IN THE GREAT ISAIAH SCROLL 


by Jeremy Chance Springfield
10/6/17

​
Picture
The detail found in the Great Isaiah Scroll / DSS text concerning Isaiah 9:7 with the term L’MAR’BEYH is that it does not possess the Mem sofit (final mem / closed mem) that the Masoretic text of Isaiah 9:7 displays.  I have asserted in my study: THE VIRGIN BIRTH IN TORAH that this detail missing from the oldest scroll of Isaiah in existence is problematic for those who attempt to use the detail that exists in the Masoretic text of Isaiah as proof of a virgin birth.  Although I am a steadfast proponent of the Scriptural validity of the miraculous, virgin birth of Messiah, this particular verse is lacking in weight to prove such doctrine.   The missing form of the Mem sofit in the Great Isaiah Scroll shows that there was a time when the term was written by scribes without such concept at play.  This means that the most ancient witness of that text does not support the letter having any significance towards pointing to the virgin birth concept, and in that way, detractors of Yeshua as having been born from a virgin could very well cite such a detail as proof against His unique and miraculous conception.

However, there are those who might instead argue that the Great Isaiah Scroll does not represent an accurate reading in this particular instance.  While I would love for that to be the case, as I attempt to pay attention to every scribal oddity and textual anomaly of Scripture that comes with a traditional, historical view attached to it, and glean from the Spirit whatever He may have intended by such detail, I think that the evidence weighs in heavily against merely dismissing the text of the Great Isaiah Scroll as one where the scribe missed including the Mem sofit in this instance.  I base this opinion not on a personal reason, but upon hard facts that have come from carefully assessing the nature of the Great Isaiah Scroll itself.

The Great Isaiah Scroll has a textual landscape that has significant bearing towards the term of question in Isaiah 9:7. The text possesses a total of twenty-six (26) different uses of the Mem sofit appearing inside of a word!  If there are more, I am not aware of them.  This far outweighs the single instance preserved in the Masoretic text of Isaiah.  Some of these appear couched within a term, as we see in the instance of the Masoretic version of Isaiah 9:7, and others appear in a unique format in that the Great Isaiah Scroll version of some terms possesses a letter Heh on the end, marking terms as feminine in gender, instead of the Mem sofit that would be expected otherwise.  Still, the presence of these Mem sofit letters inside so many terms in the Great Isaiah Scroll displays further evidence that the presence of the single Mem sofit in the Masoretic text of Isaiah 9:7 is the actual anomaly, and not the other way around. 

To further add doubt to the validity of the Mem sofit in the Masoretic text of Isaiah 9:7 is the use of such form in other texts found in the Qumran caves along with the DSS Isaiah text.  It is found not only in the text of the prophet Isaiah, but also in scattered instances in Exodus, Leviticus, Psalms, and Ezekiel, as well as many other non-canonical works preserved as part of the community’s holy texts.  Even more, there are instances in the Qumran texts of Kaf sofit letters appearing within terms – a detail that should add yet more doubt to the appearance of the Mem sofit in L’MAR’BEYH of the Masoretic text of Isaiah 9:7 as being originally significant.   The most logical reason for this is that the scribal practice at work within the Great Isaiah Scroll was not one that was codified yet, or else the prolific use of sofit letters within terms would not have been countenanced by the very strict religious regulations of the community.  What we see, then, is that the use of the sofit letters was apparently not overseen by any strict guidelines at that time.  The scribal tradition of the Masoretic version of Isaiah came after a standardization of use of the sofit letters, for they were all but eliminated in their use within terms.
​
In light of this information that is textually based and not merely personal opinion, I can only deal with the text in integrity by asserting that the presence of the Mem sofit in the Masoretic version of Isaiah 9:7 is not reflective of the original intent by the inspired writer.  For those interested, all twenty-six (26) appearances of the Mem sofit as it is used in the DSS Isaiah text have been included below, for comparison and verification of what has been discussed in this addendum to THE VIRGIN BIRTH IN TORAH.  I have bolded the letter M in the font in each transliterated example of the relevant term so the reader can further see which letter is in the unique format.  
​

Isaiah 1:6
BASHAMEN “with oil” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.
Picture

​
Isaiah 29:14
KHAKHMATH “wisdom” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.
Picture

​
Isaiah 29:17
VEHAKARMEL “and the fruitful field” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.
Picture


Isaiah 30:24
HA’ADAMAH “the ground” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


​Isaiah 32:15
LAKARMEL “for a fruitful field” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word the DSS Isaiah text.
Picture


Isaiah 34:7
ARTZAMAH “land” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word the DSS Isaiah text.
Picture


Isaiah 34:10
VEYOMAM “and day” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 41:16
OTAMAH “them” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.
Picture


Isaiah 41:18
ASIMAH “I shall make” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


​Isaiah 44:18
LIBOTAMAH “their hearts” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 45:20
PISLAMAH “idols” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 50:10
VAKEMAH “among you” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 51:2
T’KHOLELKEMAH “who gave birth to you” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 51:23
VATASIMI “and you have laid” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 52:3
NIMKARTEMAH “I have sold you” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 52:11
MISHAMAH “from there” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 55:3
NAFSHEKEMAH “your soul” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 56:7
OLOTEYHEMAH “their burnt offerings” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 57:8
MISHKAVAMAH “their bed” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture

Isaiah 58:1
PISHAHEYMAH “their transgression” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 58:12
T’QUMEYM “you shall raise up” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 59:2
VEKHATOTEYKEMAH “and your sins” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 59:3
KAFEYKEMAH “your hands” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 59:6
BEMA’ASEYHEMAH “with their works” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 61:9
ROEYHEMAH “see them” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture


Isaiah 63:6
VA’ASHAKREYMAH “and I made them drunk” possesses a Mem sofit inside the word in the DSS Isaiah text.

Picture

​All study contents Copyright Jeremy Chance Springfield, except for graphics and images, which are Copyright their respective creators.
Proudly powered by Weebly